It is impossible to comprehend the special, sanctified quality of the Land of Israel and to express ones love for it merely through finite, human understanding.
– Rav Kook, Orot Eretz Yisrael, Chap 1
The Land of Israel is a land of paradoxes. Questions that arise about Israel include: What is so special about it? Why has it been in the the focus of attention all over the world…for millennia?
And even the question of where Israel is located — which should be easy enough to answer — is complicated. So today we’re going to look at the issue of what continent Israel is a part of and see whether Israel can fit neatly into a box or not. Spoiler alert – not.
Is Israel in Europe or Asia or Africa?
The question of, which continent is Israel a part of is a great question and the answer is, it depends. In some respects it may be considered part of all three.
And according to Jewish tradition, it may even be considered a unique place all its own.
Israel as part of Asia
One of the most memorable stories of people who befriended and saved Jews during the Holocaust comes from Japan and underlines Israel’s ancient kinship with Asia. A number of Jews — who were predominantly from a city called Mir (famous for the Mir yeshiva) — had fled the Nazis via Russia and ended up all the way in Japan. When this big group of Jews got to Japan, the Japanese didn’t know what to do with them. A meeting was arranged, and three emisarries from the Jewish group were brought to see some of the Japanese officials who immediately began interrogating them, “Why do the Germans hate you so much,” they asked.
At the time, Japan and Nazi Germany were allies and the Japanese had been exposed to Mein Kamph and other anti-Semitic propaganda, which they may have been inclined to believe considering they probably hadn’t met many Jews. The downtrodden Jews had very little bargaining power with the Japanese officials. And anyway, why should the Japanese trust the Jews more than they trust their own allies, the Nazis? What could the Jews say? Still, the Amshinover Rebbe, Rabbi Shimon Kalish, spoke up and told the Japanese officer, “the reason the Germans hate us so much is because we’re Asian.”
The Japanese officials recognized the truth to that answer and it hit the mark. After the initial shock, the officer warmed up to them and even helped the remnants of the Jewish Mir community survive the war.
Geographically, the Land of Israel really is part of the Asian continent, as is the rest of the Middle East. So the answer was correct, Jews, with their ancient roots in Israel, are, in a sense, Asians.
But could the land of Israel also be considered a piece of Africa?
Israel as part of Africa
Let’s not forget that the Nation of Israel was born in Africa, Egypt to be exact, and walked its way to Israel. And, of the Jews living in Israel today, about 15% of them fare from African countries including Morrocco, Algeria, Ethiopia, and Egypt.
But is the Land of Israel actually part of the African continent in any way?
The answer is, yes! On a tectonic level, most of the Land of Israel is a part of the massive African tectonic plate. Meaning, if Africa were to be detatched from all other lands on a techtonic level, Israel would be included.
According to one mainstream scientific hypothesis, Israel’s tectonic attachment to Africa can even be seen by the naked eye. As explained in Wikipedia, the low elevation of the Dead Sea is because “the Dead Sea lies in a true rift zone, an extension of the Red Sea Rift, or even of the Great Rift Valley of eastern Africa.” In other words, the wonders of the Dead Sea are a result of it being on the ridge between the African tectonic plate and the Arabian tectonic plate – most of Israel being on the African side.
For anyone who has never experienced the wonders of the Dead Sea, its surface is 1,412 ft below sea level – the lowest place on Earth. And, since it is so salty, you can literally float on top of the surface of the water.
So, while Israel is part of Asia on a surface level, below the surface, Israel is more connected to Africa than any other landmass.
But what about Europe?
Israel as part of Europe
Although the Land of Israel is geographically part of Asia on the surface, and is part of Africa on a sub-surface tectonic level, could Israel be considered part of Europe too on some level? The answer is, not really but kind of.
Ever since the Crusades, European nations have taken steps to adopt the Land of Israel as one of their own. And in modern sports, pop culture, and politics, Israel is often considered part of Europe.
In pop culture, the State of Israel is an active member of the Eurovision song contest and has even won it 4 times.
In sports, The State of Israel is considered a European country as shown by its membership in the European Olympic Committees, the Union of European Football Association (UEFA) as well as many other European sports organizations.
Politically, most of the politicians who have served as Israel’s prime ministers were born in Europe, the Israeli government is a western-style democracy, and, although Israel is only an associated member of the European Union and not a full member, some European leaders have expressed strong desire to have the State of Israel join. In 2010, then Prime Minister of Italy Silvio Berlusconi said, “My greatest desire, as long as I am a protagonist in politics, is to bring Israel into membership of the European Union.”
So is Israel part of Europe? Not really, but in many cases the State of Israel is categorized as a European nation.
What about Israel being part of the USA?
Ha ha. No.
Israel as a land all its own
There is a passed-down Jewish tradition that says “The Land of Israel is higher than all the other lands” (Sanhedrin 77a). Being as Israel has only one mountain that is barely tall enough for skiing, and it even includes within it the lowest place on Earth, as mentioned above, it seems that the height referred to in this teaching is not physical elevation. Rather, it’s talking on a spiritual plane about the Land’s uniqueness that, according to tradition, is higher than any other land in the physical plane of existence – it’s the Holy Land.
When one considers the specialness of the Land of Israel — whether on the physical plane or on the spiritual plane — it almost makes sense that it’s so difficult to fit the small landmass into a neatly categorized box. The Torah refers to it as the “land flowing with milk and honey” and “a land that is lovely,” and the Jewish blessing said after eating a meal refers to it as a “lovely, good, and vast land.”
One thing is for sure, in a land that is only slightly larger than New Jersey (8,630 vs. 7,354 sq. miles), paradoxes abound and there is much more than meets the eye.
Now it’s your turn. What do you think about the Land of Israel? Let us know in a comment below.